Tuesday, March 9, 2010

Benefits of Formula Feeding?

I came across this article and was shocked. How freaking selfish can you be?

Many mothers today are made to feel guilty about bottle feeding their baby. The medical profession, the media, family, strangers in the street, all eulogize the benefits of breastfeeding. We're told; it's natural; it has just the right nutrients for your baby; it promotes better bonding between mother and child; it's environmentally friendly! All of these things are true to an extent but the plain fact is, many mothers do not breastfeed their child and many are made to feel like a pariah if they opt for the bottle. Promoting breastfeeding as being best is fine, but disparaging mothers who bottle feed is not.


If you are a mother who has chosen not to breastfeed, and who can't breastfeed, you must never, ever feel guilty about doing so. Today's baby milk formula is the closest it has ever been to breast milk. It also comes fortified with many nutrients that are low or absent in many mother's breast milk. Formula milk is fortified with iron and vitamin D. Fact: Iron-fortified infant formulas have actually been credited for the declining incidence of anemia in infants. For this reason, the American Academy of Pediatrics highly recommends that mothers who are not breastfeeding use an iron-fortified infant formula. So, as far as nutrition goes, a mother need have no worries about giving her baby milk formula.
Being a mother is very tiring. Infant formula milk is not as easily digested as mother's milk. Consequently, the baby feels satiated for longer periods and this extends the time between feedings at an earlier stage. So a mother who bottle feeds can get more rest between feeds than a mother who breastfeeds.

One major cause of concern for breastfeeding mothers is knowing whether or not her baby is getting enough milk. Not so with infant formula. A mother who bottle feeds her baby knows exactly how much she has fed her child and can rest easy knowing her child has received its recommended daily allowance.
A mother who bottle feeds her child can return to a more normal life than a mother who breastfeeds. A mother who bottle feeds can wear the clothes she wants; a nursing mother has to wear clothes to accommodate her hungry baby. A mother who bottle feeds can eat the diet she chooses and not have to worry about drinking alcohol; a breastfeeding mother's diet is a much duller affair. Bottle feeding mothers can take medication when the need to; a breastfeeding mother has to be very careful about any medication she takes as this will be passed on to baby through her breast milk, in fact some medication may even stop her milk production.
Lovemaking is sometimes not easy for the breastfeeding woman because the hormonal changes associated with lactation leaves her vagina dry. In addition, breastfeeding can lead to sore nipples and leaky breasts, which are not conducive to lovemaking. A bottle feeding mother should not have these problems. She also has the added benefit of being able to choose the contraception of her choice. A breastfeeding mother cannot take the oral pill as its hormones will be passed on to baby through her breast milk.
A mother who bottle feeds her child can begin to diet six weeks after delivery. A breastfeeding mother on the other hand, has to be careful about her diet.
Bottle feeding in public tends to be far less embarrassing for a mother than does breastfeeding. A consequence is that many mothers who choose to bottle feed generally venture outdoors much more than those who breastfeeding; society has not made public breastfeeding easy for mothers.
So, next time you may feel as though you're letting yourself and baby down, remember that they are many advantages to giving your baby infant formula, for both mother and child.
A friend of mine said the following:

I find these types of articles quite comical.  Majority, if not all of the benefits, are for the mother.  You don't have to feel guilty if you bottle feed, but seriously, there are no benefits to bottle feeding for the baby OVER breastfeeding.  Here's my response to every point she makes.

Today's baby milk formula is the closest it has ever been to breast milk.

And so it was 30 years ago, and 20 years ago, and 10 years ago, and will be 10 years from now.  They’re always as close as they can get for the time that we’re in, but that doesn’t mean they’re really close.  We also don’t even know all of what’s in breastmilk so it’s hard to compare.

It also comes fortified with many nutrients that are low or absent in many mother's breast milk.
Fortified is another way of saying unnaturally added vitamins.  Also, the reason that breast milk lacks these “fortified vitamins” are because we’re trying to grow human babies slowly, not cows.  Human babies don’t need as much iron as cows, and humans can’t absorb as much iron from cows either.

Infant formula milk is not as easily digested as mother's milk. Consequently, the baby feels satiated for longer periods and this extends the time between feedings at an earlier stage. So a mother who bottle feeds can get more rest between feeds than a mother who breastfeeds.

The baby is having a harder time digesting and this is a benefit?  Wow.  This is only a benefit to a mother’s sleep, which the mother will get in time and with a proper sleep routine.  If you want sleep that bad, don’t have a baby.  BTW, nursing gives the mother a time out so she has no choice but to rest. :)

A mother who bottle feeds her baby knows exactly how much she has fed her child and can rest easy knowing her child has received its recommended daily allowance.

Even better, when you don’t bottle feed you don’t have to worry at all about how much your baby is getting because as soon as they pop off and don’t want the boob anymore you can say they are done, no measuring required.  Wet diapers and weight gains are ways of knowing your baby is eating enough. BTW, if you can’t measure how much breastmilk a baby is getting, where did the recommended daily allowance come from then?

A mother who bottle feeds her child can return to a more normal life than a mother who breastfeeds.

Normal?  So I can live like I don’t have a kid anymore?  Awesome.  Er… what is normal anyways?  If we are talking about a normal body, then breastfeeding will actually help you lose weight much faster and ease your hormones rather than if you were to formula feed.

A mother who bottle feeds can wear the clothes she wants; a nursing mother has to wear clothes to accommodate her hungry baby.
I can find a way to feed my baby in anything I wear.  I can find a way to pop a boob out for the babe.

A mother who bottle feeds can eat the diet she chooses and not have to worry about drinking alcohol; a breastfeeding mother's diet is a much duller affair.
We all know that when you’re a mother you’re up at 10 AM with a full bottle of wine.  I mean really, who can drink a lot while your child is awake anyways?  If you need that much alcohol, you have a problem.  Otherwise just drink after your child has just finished nursing, it’s not hard.And I can eat pretty much anything I want!

Bottle feeding mothers can take medication when they need to; a breastfeeding mother has to be very careful about any medication she takes as this will be passed on to baby through her breast milk, in fact some medication may even stop her milk production.


This is true.  If you have a serious disease/illness/problem where you can’t stop your medication, then don’t, and choose not to breastfeed.  Likely you can breastfeed on this medication anyways. Mothers milk with medication in it still far surpasses artifical milk

Lovemaking is sometimes not easy for the breastfeeding woman because the hormonal changes associated with lactation leaves her vagina dry.  In addition, breastfeeding can lead to sore nipples and leaky breasts, which are not conducive to lovemaking.
Use lube if you’re dry, duh.  Sore nipples will either heal over a short time or your latch was/is not correct, try to fix it early.  Leaky breasts only last up to 2 months, until you stop leaking they make nursing pads, use those.  Lovemaking… who the hell wants to have sex when you have a baby anyways? Also, your husband should not care about you leaking. Find a new husband if he is bothered by it. I personally have no dry problems.

A breastfeeding mother cannot take the oral pill as its hormones will be passed on to baby through her breast milk.
A breastfeeding mother can use the mini pill if that’s her choice. A mother can also take a normal pill. The hormones passing to the baby are not the issue. There are condoms which are hormone free and probably better for you anyways.  There’s IUDs, diaphragms, and uhh just knowing when you’re fertile and avoiding.  Even better though, breastfeeding hormones usually prevent you from getting your period for about 6 months or more.  This is your body’s way of keeping you from having another baby too soon, naturally.

A mother who bottle feeds her child can begin to diet six weeks after delivery. A breastfeeding mother on the other hand, has to be careful about her diet
A fad diet to which you can’t have while you breastfeed is probably not good for the mother as well.  There are times when you have to cut dairy or certain veggies out too, but there are plenty of other foods you can eat, choose one of those.  But the great thing about breastfeeding is that nursing helps you burn calories so you don't have to "diet."

Bottle feeding in public tends to be far less embarrassing for a mother than does breastfeeding. A consequence is that many mothers who choose to bottle feed generally venture outdoors much more than those who breastfeeding; society has not made public breastfeeding easy for mothers

Actually I think breastfeeding is far less embarrassing.  I’m proud to have breastfed, why would I not want to show people what I’ve accomplished?  And the fact that the public doesn’t make it easy for mothers is a problem that society needs to get over, but the mother, she’s done nothing wrong.

8 comments:

Veronica said...

Where on earth did you find this terrible article??? I can't believe that. As she tried to make valid points, all she did was make herself sound like a moron. I am sppechless.

Veronica said...

Also, aside from that pathetic reason of "formula is has extra nutrients"...there was NOOO mention of how formula is more beneficial to the baby. This was entirely mommy based. I am appalled. After I read this I thought "No way, this has to be bogus. This has to be a joke." The sad thing is that a lot of women really and truly feel this way.

Hippie Momma said...

I know! That is why I could not believe how selfish it was. That she even listed slower digestion as a BENEFIT! Really? Yeah, give your baby something that is not meant for them so they can sleep longer. * the nurse in the hospital suggested that to me as well*

Beth said...

My jaw is on the floor. Wow. Just wow. What a horrible view to put out there. How many inexperienced mothers to be are going to read this and justify formula feeding without giving breastfeeding a try.
I am truly disgusted. Where did you find this 'article'?

Brandi said...

I wish I could chuck a shoe at the author of this article. Some poor naive new mom trying to decide whether to nurse her baby or not might be swayed to think formula is okay. BTW do you realize that formula hasn't changed in 20 to 30 years? It isn't any different or better! A dear friend of mine has also informed me that breast milk is just blood without the red blood cells. It is living and NO formula can replace that. Sheesh!!!

mandy_moo said...

this is disturbing to me. I'm perfectly ok with bottle feeding if it's a rare case where the mother literally, physically COULD NOT breast feed. This, however, is just downright selfish.

Hillary said...

I am actually really offended by this whole post and the comments. I am one who cannot breastfeed. Not for lack of trying, though. I just don't produce milk, and my babies end up failing to thrive. But that doesn't matter. How a woman chooses to feed her baby is up to her. And just because she chooses not to breastfeed, for WHATEVER reason, does not make her selfish!!!! I very much resent this kind of closed-minded opinion. As mothers, we should support each other and realize we're all doing our best instead of cutting others down and making them feel bad.

Veronica said...

Hilary, I urge you to go back and read this post again...and again. You will see that this was NOT AT ALL referencing women in your case who do not make enough milk for their babies. I'm sorry, but when you are giving reasons like "Moms who don't BF can consume alcohol..." wow. Just wow.

BTW, my second baby was only BF for 5 weeks and although I still to this day feel guilty and sad about that, I in no way put myself in the same category as the writer of this article. You shouldn't put yourself there either.

Amy posted this in hopes that a FTM would read this and see how silly and selfish...yes selfish some of her "valid" points were. Some of them such as the medication ones were valid. That is actually why I had to stop BF my second baby. But most of her reasons were 100% mommy based. This is one of the things that is severely wrong with our society. If you choose to get offended by such truth, than I am sorry.